An outstanding film—highly recommended for any true cinephile. Finally, we get something raw and fresh, without that typical, overblown American pretentiousness.
It’s a deeply human story following a successful, intelligent, and sensitive Pakistani man living in the United States, focusing primarily on his internal turmoil after being caught in events entirely beyond his control.
I think I’ve rated it somewhere before; I believe it was
8.5/10
I was actually quite glad I went into this blind, without knowing a single thing about it—that's honestly my favorite way to watch movies. I didn't read the reviews, didn't even watch the trailer, and I highly suggest you do the same. Just watch it. Even if you end up hating it, you've only lost two hours of your life—hardly a tragedy.🙂
Possible spoilers below this text!casualbadger92 said:the movie feels so superficial that by the end, you can't tell if the guy actually pivoted to religious ideology or not. What exactly drove him to that turning point isn't argued very well, and neither is the moment of the shift itself. To me, you could see where he was heading ten years before the twins even fell, even though the reasons behind it were obvious from the start. It almost feels like he became a fundamentalist just because he got pushed around a few times, like having to undergo an anal exam upon landing at a US airport. (Hyperbole intended 😁 )
I don't get the part where he leaves for Pakistan and then says when he returns that he can't stay in the United States anymore because he lacks a visa, yet he's been here since 2018? What kind of visa? 😕
Well, I think that specific part is actually portrayed beautifully—how his anger builds up (which he manages to keep under control, which is arguably the core of the entire film to me) after all the constant harassment, the condescension at work, out in public, and the discrimination he faces everywhere. It all eventually culminates in his (unjustified) arrest simply because of how he looks. You can't depict every single scene explicitly; you have to draw some conclusions yourself. But those everyday struggles he endured over several years are exactly what drove him toward certain actions. Personally, I thought it was masterfully done; I found myself empathizing with him quite easily.
And that pivotal moment when he makes his decision is, in my opinion, excellently handled (specifically that scene with the Turk), when the character realizes that through his profession, he is actually doing more harm to his own people than the US military or the bombings ever could.
As for the visa issue—it’s pretty straightforward: you have a visa for as long as you're studying. If you're working, you have a work visa. Once that ends, you either apply for citizenship or you go home. I don't see any logical flaw there. Besides, I suspect the visa excuse was mostly just something he said to the girl, since he had already made up his mind to leave regardless.
Also, I'm not sure what you mean by "religious ideology." He did turn toward religion (among other things), but he decided to become an intellectual fundamentalist, an activist. Every religion and holy book preaches love and peace.
Generally speaking, I find spirituality and ecumenism fascinating even though I'm not a believer in any faith, and one of the few quotes from the Quran I know because it's beautiful is: "If you kill one innocent person, it is as if you killed all of humanity; and if you save one life, it is as if you saved all of humanity."
And that is exactly how he chose to act. I would say he acted in a Martin Luther King Jr. fashion—using his role as a professor to instill self-awareness in young people, shaping them into intellectuals and individuals who know how to think for themselves.
I've gone ahead and laid everything out 😁