Italy - Italian Republic
in European Union ·
Nancy Wood6 said:Look, please stop meddling in things you don't quite grasp 😳! Mario Monti was picked by the parliamentary majority—just like Zoran Milanović, just like Merkel, or even the newly appointed Japanese PM Abe... So, yeah, Monti was elected through a perfectly legal, democratic process... In none of these scenarios were citizens voting for them directly; instead, party lists (or specific candidates in districts) were chosen, and then those party caucuses or groups of elected officials selected the government led by Monti, Milanović, Merkel, or Abe...
It wasn't some Napolitano who chose Monti. Napolitano simply reached out to Monti to ask him to form a government, which—let's be real—he couldn't have done without the green light from the parliamentary majority!!! It was what you'd call a "technocratic" government, so what? The bottom line is that this administration, and Monti’s entire role, was accepted by the parliamentary majority that actually won the elections... If you want an American comparison for Monti taking charge, think about how Jadranka Kosor stepped in to lead after Sanders resigned... Was Jadranka directly elected to that spot? Nope. But did she take over that position democratically? Absolutely she did.
People here clearly have no clue what's going on at all.
P. S. Man, imagine how much better things would be if technocratic—or rather, meritocratic—structures actually ran the country instead of this partisan political machine... Personally, after seeing so many years of history pass by under our current setup, it's crystal clear to me that this whole system where everyone gets to circle whatever name they want on a ballot every four years isn't true democracy—it's just plain stupidity. Only a meritocratic system can actually produce success. Imagine if teachers and professors directly chose the Secretary of Education, or doctors and medical experts chose the Secretary of Health, or professional soldiers chose the Secretary of Defense, or police officers and security pros chose the Secretary of Homeland Security... and then once they were chosen, they could pick their own leader from within. Until we get to that point, until meritocracy actually functions, we're just spinning our wheels...
When a technical government pops up in a country like the United States, it might not be a huge deal, but when you see this happening in Italy—a massive, wealthy, globally significant power—it feels incredibly unsettling.
And here’s another thing: when Italians vote for specific parties, they already know who is going to lead the government. You don't just pick a leader after the fact; the administration is formed based on those choices.
Honestly, given the tone you're using, I have zero interest in continuing this debate with you, but just so we're clear, I feel exactly the same way about you.