CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Lifestyle › Hobbies & Leisure › Best protein powders for muscle gain?

Best protein powders for muscle gain?

Started by Jonathan Miller7 · · 👁 38 views · 851 replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants Jonathan Miller7Alex Long8rustygull50Scott Ortiz3Jacob Carter6Raymond Jones5Paul Vaughn71wiredpilot30AplacidrangerAngela Lopez71Linda Rogers88Matthew Richardson81James Cruz4wearyotter81Angela Cox4rustyowl4Chloe Hughes2boldwalker9driftingtinker7darkfox85Christian Harris2Paul Kim8David Thomas362 …
Jonathan Miller7 Jonathan Miller7 NewcomerOP
1 message
joined Nov 2008
#281 ·
Nicholas Chavez70 said:Look, this isn't even about politics... It’s just that these guys need to actually step up and be competitive like everyone else in the USA, instead of just planning how they're going to go out and buy a BMW X5 after barely a year on the job...

"Competitive"? Give me a break. We're dealing with pure, unadulterated incompetence over here. Honestly, things can't stay this way forever.
nimbleskipper89 nimbleskipper89 Member
27 messages
joined Aug 2010
#282 ·
Nicholas Chavez70 said:It’s really not even a political issue... It’s more about whether these gentlemen can actually learn to be competitive like they are in the rest of the USA—instead of just planning how they'll go out and buy a BMW X5 after only a year on the job...

..I was simply stating that I am quite satisfied with the brand I use (think of something like General Mills)—it’s actually a few percentage points cheaper here than it is in the rest of the USA, so you can't claim it isn't competitive. As for why certain American products are priced so high here while being much more affordable back home? I won't even touch that subject, as I have no idea where those massive price discrepancies originate. Perhaps the quality isn't quite everything they claim it is when they market it to us locally.
Nicholas Chavez70 Nicholas Chavez70 Active Member
72 messages
joined Jan 2008
#283 ·
nimbleskipper89 said:..I wrote that it's a brand I am incredibly satisfied with (Inkospor), and since it's actually a few percent cheaper here than it is in the USA, you really can't say it isn't competitive. As for why American products are so pricey here while they remain cheap in Canada, I won't even bother commenting because I have no clue where those massive price gaps come from. Perhaps the quality isn't quite what they claim it to be in our neck of the woods.

I finished off a tub of Inkospor Xtreme Whey a few months back, and frankly, when it comes to flavor or how well it actually dissolves in water or milk, it ranks at a absolute zero compared to Dymatize Elite... It was nothing but clumps, a total mess... 👎 Regarding Dymatize Elite, all I've heard is praise, and that's not just here in the US, but internationally as well... For now, personally, I can't say much about it myself since I've only just started using it, but after a month or so, I'll be able to offer my own two cents...😉
Ethan Garcia8 Ethan Garcia8 Active Member
51 messages
joined Sep 2017
#284 ·
Nicholas Chavez70 said:I finished my tub of Xtreme Whey a few months back, and honestly, compared to Dymatize Elite, it’s not even in the same league. In terms of flavor or how well it actually dissolves in water or milk, I'd give it a zero. It's just a mess of clumps. 👎 Regarding Dymatize Elite, I’ve heard nothing but rave reviews about it, both here in the States and abroad. I can't give you my own take just yet since I only recently started using it, but once I've been on it for a month or two, I'll be happy to weigh in. 😉

It’s true—the solubility of that stuff is an absolute Inca catastrophe. On the other hand, Dymatize Elite is easily a top-tier protein and probably the most popular Whey on the planet.

I had some digestive issues every single time I used that strawberry flavor from Scitec. On the other hand, Dymatize sits really well on my stomach.
Nicholas Chavez70 Nicholas Chavez70 Active Member
72 messages
joined Jan 2008
#285 ·
Ethan Garcia8 said:It is an absolute fact that the solubility of that stuff is an Inca catastrophe. Dymatize Elite is legitimately a 5+ star protein and arguably the most popular Whey on the planet right now.

I recall having digestive issues every single time I tried that Inka brand strawberry flavor. On the other hand, Dymatize sits perfectly on my stomach without any drama.

Out of all the massive protein quantities I have had the opportunity to test, I found the strawberry flavor from Labrada V60 to be the best, though honestly, that specific formula rarely turns out well enough that you don't end up tossing it in the trash after a while... 😁 The stuff from Scitec was the worst of the bunch... I was also quite disappointed by how Weider protein 80 handled solubility... For a company with such a high reputation, they aren't ranking particularly high in my book... Vanilla is pretty much the same everywhere you go, so I almost never make a mistake when I stick to that...
Christian Harris2 Christian Harris2 Member
12 messages
joined Apr 2010
#286 ·
nimbleskipper89 said:I don't really feel that way either, though I suppose since we tend to be so quick to criticize everything homegrown—calling it low quality or overpriced and so on—if we aren't willing to support our own, we can't really expect miracles. It isn't about politics, necessarily, but more about mindset. At the end of the day, everyone decides where to spend their money, but if you're always busy fixing up someone else's yard, your own is probably going to stay a mess forever. Don't tell me I'm being philosophical; I just tend to look at things from a slightly broader perspective than just my own wallet.

If I spend all my time tending to the neighbor's yard, eventually I might just end up moving in next door. ☕ You know what I mean? It's not like I'm trying to lecture you with some intense patriotism. 🤷

briskjackal5 said:Besides that, I agree it isn't dangerous when taken in normal amounts.

I guess you didn't finish reading the article I linked, did you? Or maybe you're just looking for comfort? 🙂 The reality is that people everywhere are essentially poisoning themselves through food and drink for all sorts of questionable reasons.

briskjackal5 said:I ask because the whole process of ranking proteins seems to me to be just as common as hearing stuff like, "I heard people say Multipower is garbage because they pack it in Canada," or, "Twinlab is a rip-off because it's too expensive." Most opinions seem to be formed that way.
And then, almost by accident and depending on what's being whispered through the grapevine, attitudes toward specific brands start to solidify.
I suspect that's how it works for about 99% of users.

Yeah, that's unfortunately how my opinion of Scitec formed as well. There were rumors that the importer was doing something shady with the containers—like the lids weren't sealed properly, so they'd take some out and replace it with something else. 😕 But again, those are just rumors. I bought it. Tried it. And it seems fine to me. 🤷 It actually tastes better than Dymatize. Personally, I think the whole idea of ranking products is a bit pointless. Everyone has different preferences. You could determine which product has the highest or best quality protein, but even then, it feels a bit redundant since most major brands use basically the same manufacturing methods.

I suppose one could determine which product contains the fewest undesirable ingredients, specifically heavy metals. Based on what I've gathered so far, I might suggest Gold Standard by Optimum Nutrition. Their Whey Gold and Hydro Whey have shown some of the lowest metal concentrations during testing. It seems even certain types of vegetables might contain more metals than their products. So 🙏. I know I read this somewhere recently, though I can't seem to locate the link right now.

Also, I was wondering why you sign off at the end of every single post? 😕

nimbleskipper89 said:..I mentioned that it's a brand I am quite happy with (Inkospor), and it's actually a few percent cheaper here than in the USA, so it's hard to say it isn't competitive. As for why American products are so expensive for us while they are cheap in Canada, I won't comment because I don't really know where those massive price gaps come from. Perhaps the quality isn't quite as high as it's presented to be here.

It is actually the exact same products and the exact same packaging.
nimbleskipper89 nimbleskipper89 Member
27 messages
joined Aug 2010
#287 ·
Nicholas Chavez70 said:I burned through my tub of Xtreme Whey a few months back—and honestly, if we’re talking about flavor profile or how well it actually dissolves in water or milk, it’s a total zero compared to Dymatize Elite... just massive clumps everywhere... 👎 As for Dymatize Elite, I've heard nothing but glowing reviews, not just here in the States but internationally too... Personally, I can't weigh in quite yet since I just started using it, but after a month or two, I'll be happy to throw in my two cents... 😉

..I haven't had that experience, and I've tried almost every flavor they offer. It used to foam up like crazy, but the folks at my gym told me that was because it was basically fat-free. Apparently, they bumped the fat content up by about 1%, so it doesn't bubble up nearly as much now. At least, that's what I was told.
nimbleskipper89 nimbleskipper89 Member
27 messages
joined Aug 2010
#288 ·
Ethan Garcia8 said:It’s an absolute fact—the solubility of that stuff is an Inca catastrophe. On the other hand, Dymatize Elite is genuinely 5-star quality and probably the most popular Whey on the planet.

With the strawberry flavor from MusclePharm, I dealt with digestive issues every single time—total nightmare. Dymatize, however, sits perfectly on my stomach.

...maybe you were dealing with something else entirely, but at this point, it's fine to vent a little...
Ethan Garcia8 Ethan Garcia8 Active Member
51 messages
joined Sep 2017
#289 ·
Not really. I’m not one to make a scene for nothing. Honestly, I couldn't care less about that Inca catastrophe.
nimbleskipper89 nimbleskipper89 Member
27 messages
joined Aug 2010
#290 ·
Ethan Garcia8 said:Hardly. I’m not just making noise for the sake of hearing myself talk—I simply couldn't care less about Inka catastrophe.

..who exactly are you, you hyperactive type? Honestly, who cares what's bothering you... a little decency wouldn't hurt.
jadefalcon6 jadefalcon6 Newcomer
2 messages
joined May 2010
#291 ·
Can anyone recommend some high-quality whey proteins that actually taste good?
Sam Roberts Sam Roberts Active Member
218 messages
joined Sep 2007
#292 ·
jadefalcon6 said:Can anyone recommend some high-quality whey proteins that actually taste good?

BSN Syntha-6

or maybe

Dymatize Elite
Brenda Sanders56 Brenda Sanders56 Active Member
130 messages
joined Aug 2012
#293 ·
I could really use some advice here... The specific Whey I was looking for isn't in stock, but they do have this Gold Standard by Optimum Nutrition in a 2.2kg tub. They also have Ultra Whey Pro, which is slightly cheaper—though honestly, the price difference is pretty negligible—and it comes in a larger 3kg tub. 🤷

I mostly just lift for fun and fitness, and I've realized that using this as part of my diet actually works out great... So, which of these two should I go with? 🤷
Sam Roberts Sam Roberts Active Member
218 messages
joined Sep 2007
#294 ·
if this Gold Standard by Optimum Nutrition is anything, then that
Brenda Sanders56 Brenda Sanders56 Active Member
130 messages
joined Aug 2012
#295 ·
Yeah.
nimblegull23 nimblegull23 Member
16 messages
joined Oct 2006
#296 ·
jadefalcon6 said:Can anyone suggest some high-quality whey proteins that actually taste good?

Gold Standard by Optimum Nutrition is solid.
Alex Long8 Alex Long8 Member
21 messages
joined Aug 2007
#297 ·
MVP Pro whey
briskjackal5 briskjackal5 Active Member
249 messages
joined Feb 2018
#298 ·
Christian Harris2 said:I mean, you didn't actually finish reading that article I linked, did you? Or maybe you're just trying to comfort yourself? 🙂 The truth is, basically everyone in America is being poisoned by what they eat and drink for all sorts of questionable reasons.

I don't really get this part, I'm not sure what you're even aiming at here.

Nah, I didn't read it. Honestly, I don't bother reading most of the articles people link.

-Stipe
Taylor Cook63 Taylor Cook63 Member
18 messages
joined Dec 2008
#299 ·
What’s everyone’s take on those proteins they stock over at Walgreens for $13? 🤷

On a broader note, does anyone know of any high-quality proteins that don't taste gross when mixed with milk—maybe something fruit-based that actually holds its own in terms of quality?

Where are you guys usually picking up your tubs? If we aren't allowed to drop links here because of the rules, just shoot me a DM, thanks!
Jonathan Miller7 Jonathan Miller7 NewcomerOP
1 message
joined Nov 2008
#300 ·
Taylor Cook63 said:What's the verdict on those proteins they stock over at Delta Air Lines for $13? 🤷

Man, you get what you pay for.

In general, does anyone know of any protein powders that don't require milk—like something fruit-based—but still actually maintain high quality?

The only ones I've seen with fruit flavors are just flavored that way; it's purely for taste. Realistically, fruit doesn't really contain protein. I mean, there's a tiny amount in there, but it's basically negligible.

Where do you guys buy your protein? If ads aren't allowed here, just shoot me a DM, thanks.

Well, it depends on where you're living. Every decent-sized US city should have a specialized shop somewhere. You can always check out a health food store if you're desperate, or honestly, just order something online. It's much easier.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads