CheckEmoji Community · the emoji forum
🏠 Home 🆕 What's new ❓ Unanswered 🔥 Popular 📡 RSS Members 👥 0 online log in · register
Home › Lifestyle › Hobbies & Leisure › Best protein powders for muscle gain?

Best protein powders for muscle gain?

Started by feralbison4 · · 👁 148 views · 1.9K replies

📡 Subscribe to replies

Participants feralbison4Bryan Fowler4Jamie Ruiz5James Lewis6Matthew White3silvergull68stormyheron4copperwolf112Ryan Robinson10boldfox8dustyotter11Grace Taylor35Roger Richardson61Henry Alvarez78Mark Hill3briskjackal5Jason Campbell70ironwolf52vividorca453slytrucker47goldenfox24Michael Chavezjadetiger962Olivia Kelly46 …
Laura Harris5 Laura Harris5 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Apr 2009
#1041 ·
Look, I don't have time to slog through dozens of pages of research just to find out which foods actually pack the most punch—specifically the stuff found in those whey supplements bodybuilders obsess over
Is it boiled chicken, breaded cutlets, granola, or just plain boiled egg whites??
bluestag7 bluestag7 Member
13 messages
joined Oct 2008
#1042 ·
Man, you have to be incredibly lazy not to just read the post right above yours! 🙄
Laura Harris5 Laura Harris5 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Apr 2009
#1043 ·
I clicked the link—it just lists calories and fats... and then there’s this "benacevina" thing. Is that supposed to be proteins? Or what...
Betty Gonzalez30 Betty Gonzalez30 Active Member
55 messages
joined Dec 2003
#1044 ·
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=whey+protein+benefits
Laura Harris5 Laura Harris5 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Apr 2009
#1045 ·
So, what’s actually the difference between plant-based fats and animal fats—do they pack on the weight just the same? And does the plant stuff have more protein?
Patrick Moore11 Patrick Moore11 Newcomer
4 messages
joined Jan 2013
#1046 ·
At what age does it actually make sense to start messing with protein supplements? Thanks!
briskjackal5 briskjackal5 Active Member
249 messages
joined Feb 2018
#1047 ·
Patrick Moore11 said:At what age does it actually start being good to take protein supplements? Thanks!

Well, I guess from day one!

-Steve
Patrick Moore11 Patrick Moore11 Newcomer
4 messages
joined Jan 2013
#1048 ·
😁

They claim 17 or 18 is the sweet spot... and anything lower is basically poison for your system—is there actually any truth to that?
coastalbison12 coastalbison12 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Sep 2007
#1049 ·
Patrick Moore11 said:😁

They say 17 or 18 is the sweet spot... and anything lower than that is bad for your body. Is there any truth to that?

Life itself isn't exactly great for the body.

The longer you live, the older and weaker your system gets, etc.
stormyheron4 stormyheron4 Active Member
86 messages
joined Aug 2009
#1050 ·
Patrick Moore11 said:😁

They say the sweet spot is between 17 and 18 grams... and anything less than that is basically useless for your body. Is there any truth to that?

Nah, definitely not.
Laura Harris5 Laura Harris5 Newcomer
3 messages
joined Apr 2009
#1051 ·
Is plant fat really the same thing as animal fat? Does one make you gain more weight than the other...
Sam Roberts Sam Roberts Active Member
218 messages
joined Sep 2007
#1052 ·
briskjackal5 said:Since day one.

-Stipe


😂😂
crimsoncanyon97 crimsoncanyon97 Newcomer
1 message
joined May 2009
#1053 ·
So, I picked up some Optimum Nutrition, and now I’m sitting here wondering about the best way to actually use it—and more importantly, what kind of results I should realistically be looking for.
jadetiger962 jadetiger962 Member
31 messages
joined Jun 2006
#1054 ·
crimsoncanyon97 said:I ended up picking up some Optimum Nutrition, and now I'm sitting here wondering how I should actually be using it and what kind of results I should realistically look for.

What was going through your head when you decided to grab it? Like, what’s the plan—how are you planning to incorporate it into your routine?
swiftlynx6 swiftlynx6 Member
16 messages
joined Apr 2009
#1055 ·
First, you really need to mention what your line of work is before anyone can suggest a specific application for you...

LP
Jamie Rivera70 Jamie Rivera70 Newcomer
2 messages
joined Aug 2010
#1056 ·
briskjackal5 said:Since day one!

-Stipe

Tell 'em like it is, Stipe! 😁

🤣
restlessmason54 restlessmason54 Member
40 messages
joined Jun 2020
#1057 ·
Hey there. I’ve been training pretty consistently for about six months now without touching any supplements, and while I can definitely see the progress in the mirror, the sheer volume of food I have to shove down my throat is becoming a massive headache. Honestly, it’s getting frustrating, so I’m looking into switching over to some pure concentrates to make things easier. Is it actually okay to drink whey protein three times a day? A buddy of mine keeps insisting they’re strictly for post-workout use, but I’m not sold on that logic. Also, what’s the real deal when comparing standard whey to those "mass gainer" products? Is there a fundamental difference, or is "mass gainer" just a fancy branding trick for the same stuff? Regarding my daily intake—if I’m aiming for roughly two grams of protein per kilo of body weight—how many grams of whey am I allowed to consume? Would it be alright to hit maybe 100–150 grams of whey spread across three servings (maybe taking half right after my workout and the other 50–100 grams integrated into my regular meals)? Oh, and one more thing: is it fine to mix it with milk, and does using whole milk instead of skim make much of a difference? Lastly, does anyone know if adding grape sugar to my whey is a good move? I heard it’s great for a quick carb hit after training to help with recovery.
Roger Richardson61 Roger Richardson61 Member
39 messages
joined Apr 2005
#1058 ·
restlessmason54 said:Hey everyone. I’ve been training pretty consistently for about six months now without touching any supplements at all. I can definitely see some progress in the mirror, which is great, but man, the sheer amount of food I have to shovel down is starting to drive me crazy. It’s honestly getting a bit frustrating. Because of that, I’m finally looking into adding some pure concentrates to my routine to help hit those numbers.

I think you've got it all wrong. Protein powder isn't some magic replacement for actual food. It’s just a supplement, not a whole meal plan.

restlessmason54 said:Can you drink whey protein three times a day? A buddy of mine keeps insisting they're strictly for post-workout only.

Whey is honestly perfect right after you hit the gym because that high glycemic index and quick digestion time just hit different when your muscles are hungry. That’s exactly why I don't really touch it at any other time of day besides breakfast. If you're looking to sip on protein throughout the afternoon, you should probably stick to casein instead of whey. Then again, you still need carbs if you actually want a decent meal, so you can't just live off shakes. A solid shake would need something like 30 grams of casein mixed with about a hundred grams of oats. Personally? I think it’s way easier—and definitely tastes better—to just throw everything into a sandwich.

restlessmason54 said:What's the real deal when you compare standard Whey to those Mega Mass blends? Is there actually a functional difference, or is it just clever branding to make people pay extra for a different label?

"Mega Mass" is just one of those names people slap on protein and carb blends, and honestly? It’s a total rip-off. You’re basically paying the same price as you would for pure Optimum Nutrition, but instead of getting high-quality fuel, you're just paying extra for a bunch of added sugar that you could easily buy at any grocery store for pennies. $6.75I usually stick to a mix of protein per kilogram and then some complex carbs—the kind you can just grab at a local grocery store like Kroger or Whole Foods. $3.25It’s about that weight per kilogram when you look at it in the form of rolled oats.

restlessmason54 said:So, I was thinking about protein intake today. If we’re following that standard rule of thumb—aiming for about 2 grams of protein per kilo of body weight—how much actual whey powder should I be hitting daily? I was wondering if a setup like this would work: maybe 100 to 150 grams of whey spread out over three shakes? I'd probably knock back half of that right after my workout, and then let the other 50 to 100 grams come from my regular meals. Does that math hold up?

Look, you could technically chug 200 grams of whey a day if you really wanted to, but honestly? You’re just throwing money down the drain. I learned that the hard way back when I was trying to hit my macros by living off shakes—total waste of cash. Using whey as your primary protein source is a bad move. It’s fine for a quick fix in the morning or right after a workout, but that's about it. You need to aim for at least two grams of protein per kilogram of body weight. If you're only hitting maybe 50 to 100 grams from real food plus a shake after training, you aren't getting nearly enough. Try to get at least 150 grams from actual meals first, then use the whey as an extra boost. Your wallet and your gains will thank you.
To keep those muscles fed, you really need a steady stream of protein coming in throughout the day. It’s all about eating more frequent meals so your digestion stays consistent. If you just rely on drinking Optimum Nutrition three times a day, your body gets its fix for maybe thirty minutes, and then it's basically fasting the rest of the time.

restlessmason54 said:Can I mix it with milk? And does using whole milk make a difference?

Sure you can, but honestly, it doesn't make much sense—you're better off with water. As for the fat content, if it didn't matter, skim milk wouldn't even be a thing.

restlessmason54 said:Why would anyone add dextrose to their Whey? I heard it's actually great after a workout since it's a fast-acting carb.

Exactly. You need carbs to replenish your muscle glycogen. Since your glycogen stores get totally wiped out during a heavy session, sipping on some dextrose is a solid way to get that fuel back into your muscles quickly.
restlessmason54 restlessmason54 Member
40 messages
joined Jun 2020
#1059 ·
Thanks for such a thorough breakdown 🙂
So, what would you suggest I do instead?
My current plan is hitting some Optimum Nutrition with my oats in the morning (about 30 grams), then following up with an 80-gram serving of Whey right after my workout—though, obviously, that doesn't include my main meals and snacks, where I'm pulling in another 90 to 100 grams from actual food. Do you think there's any real point in picking up some casein on top of all that?
To give you a better idea of where I'm at, I'm standing about 6'4" and weighing in around 220 pounds (mostly well-distributed mass), so I'm wondering if this intake is enough to see some decent progress.

Also, I have to ask—is there any actual downside to consuming protein this directly? Even though it's Whey and technically derived from natural sources, I know there's a bit of processing involved, so does it cause any harm to the body?
velvetraven velvetraven Newcomer
4 messages
joined Apr 2010
#1060 ·
I honestly think hitting 80 grams of Whey right after a workout is overkill—your body can really only process about 50 grams at once (maybe a bit more given your size/mass), and anything beyond that just sits there waiting to be processed, which essentially means you're just flushing money down the toilet. Two scoops—about 60g total—is more than enough. Casein, on the other hand, is what you want to drink in the evening before bed because it digests slowly—we're talking about a six-hour window—so it keeps your system fueled throughout the night until breakfast. You can get similar results from dairy products like cottage cheese, but if you prefer the convenience or find it more cost-effective, just grab some casein powder to take before sleep.

Given your overall mass, 200g of protein should be your absolute baseline. Honestly, you probably need even more than that.

You must log in or register to reply here.

Log in Register

🔗 Similar threads