briskhound2 said:First off—this whole thread feels like it’s missing the point. Honestly, it would have been way more interesting if you guys had picked great actors who just happened to end up in terrible movies. Because this list...
David Spade, Adam Sandler, Ashton Kutcher, Will Ferrell... we’re basically looking at a lineup of comedians who pretty much specialize in making mindless junk. Like, Spade doesn't really do "serious," Sandler was actually stellar in Punch-Drunk Love, Kutcher wasn't half bad in Steve Jobs, and Will Ferrell doesn't exactly have a catalog of dramatic roles. 🤷 It makes you wonder what kind of actors they’d actually be if they stepped out of their comfort zones or worked with a legit, talented director for once. Take Cameron Diaz—she basically saved Arnold Schwarzenegger from a role so wooden it could've been used for firewood, turning it into a career highlight. Or look at Robin Williams, who practically walked up and grabbed an Oscar once he got a real serious part. Even Jim Carrey absolutely crushed it in The Show. Then you’ve got the crew that actually knows how to act—guys like Eric Roberts, Michael Madsen, and Nicolas Cage—but they clearly couldn't care less because they just jump into these total disasters, grab the paycheck, and call it a day.
Well, I have to disagree. People are just USED to seeing Sandler, Carrey, and those types of folks in mindless comedies playing the exact same characters over and over. The second they film something DIFFERENT from what we're ACCUSTOMED to, everyone immediately goes, "Wow, look how versatile he is!" or "Look how good he can actually act!" This line of thinking follows that typical Hollywood Oscar logic, where a DIFFERENT role automatically lands a star an Oscar nomination. And if they play someone with a disability? Success is basically guaranteed.
In short, Sandler, Carrey, and the rest are ACTORS—meaning, by default, they are professionals capable of performing (or at least should be) DIFFERENT types of roles. When they finally do, people act like it’s some sort of miracle.