hollowseal33 said:you should know that intelligence isn't the same thing as being smart🙂 i don't think music needs to sound "smart." Okay, maybe I used the word intelligence wrong; what I really meant was talent... having those mental gears aligned so you can see a melody in nothing and actually express it🙂
So, does that mean the benchmark for good music is just the talent behind it?😕
Expressing a melody isn't about talent—it's about style. At least when we're talking about pop music. And to have style, you need awareness. In my eyes, the most talented musician in mainstream genres is someone like Mr. Huljić. But he has zero style... no awareness... he’s just a hack. Sure, you can respect the money he's made (if money is what impresses you)
I hate bringing this up because I don't want to be that guy, but... there's a clear generational gap here. It comes down to how "serious" versus how "fun" you take music. My perspective isn't better or "smarter," it's just fundamentally different from yours. It's that postmodernist mindset that (in my opinion) erodes everything today... the idea that "it's all good because... I don't know... it makes people happy." Basically, don't dig deep and don't overthink it. Honestly, that attitude is healthier and closer to human nature, but it has one fatal flaw: you can't build anything from it. You can't create. You undermine every criterion except "it feels good to me." You aren't disciplined. Plus, that mindset leaves you wide open to pure consumerism.
I don't want to kill the vibe here with my overly intense views, but seriously, can you imagine a time when people would actually fight over music? Yeah, it sounds idiotic now... but they cared more somehow.