Edward Flores4 said:No... I meant exactly what you said... just being comfortable with the obvious truth that people are products of their culture, rather than the other way around.
With that in mind, I’m guessing you see the whole blogosphere as something that actually cheapens culture—or maybe, more accurately, as this new kind of "culture" built on transparent, decentralized individualism that eventually leads us toward a total awakening of the collective unconscious...?
Because after that first accidental turning point brought on by Gutenberg... honestly, it would surprise me if more accidents didn't follow suit. 🙂
It is certainly possible, though one might argue that such an undertaking invites a certain level of unnecessary complication. Is it truly worth the effort? Perhaps not.
What exactly should we make of these "products" who find themselves dissatisfied with their "manufacturers"? Especially in those instances where they seem to be actively working against the very entity that shaped them? I suppose one must wonder. Personally, I prefer to extend a certain degree of credit to the individual... though perhaps it is more useful to frame the dilemma this way: on a macro level, people are merely the products of a top-down cultural model. Yet, on a micro level, the individual produces culture—or perhaps "counterculture"—no matter how minuscule or insignificant that resistance might feel against the prevailing tide.
shamantrixx said:Given the current trajectory of things, I assume you view the blogosphere as a significant blow to traditional culture? Or perhaps, more accurately, you see it as a burgeoning "culture" of transparent, decentralized individualism—one that might ultimately lead us toward a collective realization of the subconscious?
Precisely that. I have encountered certain blog posts online that, quite frankly, were more eye-opening than many published volumes that supposedly aim for the same profound effect. It leads one to wonder: why is that? Perhaps it is because "ordinary" individuals—those documenting their thoughts on a personal blog—have a natural inclination toward simplification. They possess a knack for finding practical, real-world applications for complex ideas, whereas those with formal academic credentials often seem lost in their own theoretical abstractions. Is it possible that true clarity is found in the everyday rather than the ivory tower?
Ultimately, whatever it is that forces you to pause and actually reconsider your own stances or long-held convictions—it is, in the end, a productive exercise. Whether you actually pivot your position or decide to stand your ground remains secondary; either way, you emerge having gained a new perspective. Is there not value in simply understanding how another mind operates?