Sean Stewart said:And let’s be real—what sane person is going to babysit a student who tested positive? A teacher isn't there to act as a diagnostic judge to determine if a result is a fluke or the real deal. Graduation exams are a once-in-a-lifetime event, and it’s a massive problem if you're unlucky enough to get hit with a positive test on that specific day. It’s like if someone had crashed their car in a crosswalk back in 2013—they’d miss their window through no fault of their own. Or if a dog bit them on the way to school. Those are rare scenarios now, I suppose, though I suspect it’s equally rare for someone who actually took precautions to end up in isolation—and even rarer for it to be a false positive. But this isolation issue isn't just about students or schools; it affects everyone. Positive tests mean people are sidelined from everything—traveling, attending funerals for loved ones, you name it.
If a student plays it smart before finals and avoids large crowds, theoretically, they shouldn't even end up in quarantine—after all, who’s going to report them as a contact? These exams take place long enough after regular classes end that being stuck in isolation because of a classmate or a teacher isn't really an issue.
As for other situations, plenty of adults take precautions a few days before major events just to stay healthy—say, so they can head back to work in Germany or somewhere similar. I know people in my circle who work in Austria, Germany, and places like that; they come home maybe once a month, and during those few days, they skip the birthdays and the restaurants just to avoid catching anything. If they test positive, they can't fly back to their jobs, and many of them are looking at pay cuts or even losing their positions entirely, especially since most are on fixed-term contracts.
You simply cannot force a teacher, or anyone else for that matter, to gamble with their own health by hosting a student who has a confirmed positive test.
I wasn't suggesting testing every single graduate—just those currently in isolation who are requesting to sit for the exam. I'm certain there aren't hundreds of thousands of those cases.
I wouldn't have an issue with it myself. I'm young, I've already had COVID, so the risk is basically zero, and honestly, the worst part of the whole ordeal would just be sitting there for three hours doing absolutely nothing. And that goes for the healthy students too—those who test positive but show no symptoms, or what people are calling "asymptomatic" in this so-called "new normal" era.
And no, I'm not suggesting this makes me some kind of modern-day hero, but given the circumstances and my own immunity, why shouldn't I step up and help someone avoid losing an entire school year over something so trivial?