Physical Desires vs. Human Dignity and Unfulfilled Dreams...
in Philosophy ·
casualwolf12 said:I suspect many have fundamentally misconstrued the priest’s remark regarding her departing "with honor and dignity." It seems there is a widespread misunderstanding at play here. I don't believe he was referring to some external, third-party standard of dignity—as if she were somehow forfeiting her reputation or her perceived innocence in the eyes of her parents or the local community. Rather, I would argue his comment pertained entirely to her own internal perspective. Is it not more likely that the loss of dignity is a matter of self-perception? That is certainly my contention.
From my particular vantage point, if I were to find myself being brutally dispatched by a silverback gorilla and stuffed into a shipping crate, I suspect I would feel at least a marginal sense of lost dignity. Is there truly any individual among us who wouldn't experience a certain erosion of self-respect when forced into actions—or subjected to circumstances—against their own volition? One would assume that the preservation of agency is central to the human condition, wouldn't they? To be coerced, whether by nature or by force, seems inherently contrary to the maintenance of one's pride. 🤷
As for her father, perhaps he finds some small, hollow comfort in the fact that she wasn't assaulted before the murder occurred. Or perhaps that is merely a delusion? I suspect the reality hasn't truly sunk in yet, especially considering how visibly shaken he appeared when those reporters were badgering him for a statement.
What kind of innocence are we talking about here?
Are we discussing the purity of a divine being, or just the fact that nobody has managed to tear a hymen yet (which is something we can't possibly know)?
from my own perspective, if some massive brute tied me up and forced themselves on me, I think I’d feel at least a slight loss of dignity. Honestly, I don't think there's a soul alive who wouldn't feel their dignity stripped away by actions taken under duress, against their will... 🤷
Most people would likely feel that loss of dignity.
Personally, I would feel violated. But there is a profound difference between feeling violated because someone forced something upon you and feeling a loss of dignity because of something you brought upon yourself.
I can't help but wonder what kind of reaction a priest would have to the desecration of a corpse?
Specifically, regarding sexual acts involving one. Would that be considered desecration? Would the clergy and the Church actually be outraged by it, or would they simply argue that once the spirit leaving the body has occurred, the remains are just a body? 🙄 Yes, I realize we are drifting from the main topic... but I find it equally hypocritical.
I fail to see why an unfortunate girl should be hailed as a hero, even if it's "just" to provide comfort to her family.
This whole situation just proves that both the Church and society still view survivors of assault through the exact same lens. There is still this underlying layer of disgust and contempt, acting as if the victims themselves are somehow to blame. 🤮 You see it clearly in a case like this, where the victim wasn't even assaulted in the traditional sense.
It would honestly be better to die than to face such a violation. Jesus. 🙄