Bradley Morgan3 said:Instead of the moderators (always) just deleting posts, they should probably just mark them as hidden—not totally gone, mind you, but just invisible to anyone who isn't actually participating in that specific discussion thread.
Honestly, I just don't see the point here. If you have access to the forum, you should be able to see the entire discussion and decide for yourself if you want to jump in, regardless of whether you've been active in that thread before.
First off, people wouldn't complain about the mods nearly as much, which would reduce that sense of unfairness, while giving the moderators way more breathing room to do their jobs.
I'm really not sure what there'd be less to complain about, though... because at the end of the day, someone is either going to think a moderator made the right call or they aren't, and that's where the grievance comes from. In fact, if a moderator started marking text as "hidden" when other users actually wanted to see it—or vice versa—people would probably just find even more things to whine about!
Secondly, discussions would feel much more spontaneous and free-flowing. Plus, nobody could ever accuse this site of hosting inappropriate content since it would effectively be private and tucked away from the general public eye.
Look, if content is truly inappropriate, it shouldn't be on an American forum in the first place.
Thirdly, it would prevent those situations where people jumping into a thread feel totally out of the loop because they missed everything that happened while they were away (which, by the way, can be incredibly frustrating).
But it's not just about missing the stuff that shouldn't have happened; they'd also miss out on all the genuinely useful information being shared.
Fourthly, this system would actually encourage lurkers to start participating since they'd get a peek at the hidden content.
Oh, maybe they'd join in once they saw something interesting was hidden, but how am I supposed to know there's a fascinating debate happening that I'd love to join if I can't even see it? 🙂 Just having some vague hint somewhere that someone might be mentioning something I care about isn't nearly as motivating as actually being able to read the thread and follow along in real-time.