Eric Rodriguez7 said:It would be fine if they hadn't gone and thrown in all these new characters. If I could say, "Yeah, look, they cut people because of pandemic protocols to keep the crew size down on set," I'd take it. But nah, they just invented new people instead.
People love to claim it’s "just like the cartoon," but that logic doesn't really hold up once you start adding new characters. You can't honestly tell me it's the exact same story if the original version didn't even have those people in it.
It feels a bit silly and forced, honestly. You’ve got a white father and a Black daughter. Maybe the mother was Black? They don't even mention her in the trailer. Regardless, making her dark-skinned goes against everything the original animation and books planted in people's imaginations. Now they're going to change something that's been set in stone for 150 years. It’s like trying to overhaul a long-standing tradition. If that's the case, just change the title already—it isn't the same story anymore. I'm not against Black actors, but Disney didn't need to do this. Turning the little mermaid from a light-skinned character into a Black one just feels unnecessary.
I honestly wouldn't mind if there were some hypothetical race of underwater people who happened to look Black.
The issue lies elsewhere.
The second you introduce race into a fairy tale, things get messy.
It stops being a magical fable and starts becoming a story about racial dynamics.
Judging by the ships, the wardrobe, and the architecture, it’s pretty obvious this world is modeled after the 18th century.
Back then, Black people were viewed as inferior, and the slave trade was just part of the landscape—along with every other kind of social inequality imaginable.
Which means that prince and his entourage would, by any modern standard, be hardcore racists.
If a young Black woman showed up, it would be totally unrealistic to think an aristocrat would see her as anything other than a temporary distraction. Love? Please. No way.
So, what? Are we supposed to assume that in this fictional 18th-century setting, racism simply doesn't exist?
Fine.
But there are princes.
Meaning, there is a ruling class that holds all the weapons and suppresses everyone who isn't "blue blood."
That’s actually a much deeper issue than racism, but the movie doesn't touch it.
The upper class lives off the backs of everyone else, but hey, as long as they aren't racists, everything is fine.
All the sins of the aristocracy are forgiven, provided there's a romance between a Black woman and a prince.
Just don't make it a Black woman and a poor fisherman.
When you scratch beneath the surface of these Disney stories, it gets pretty gross. It’s all about maintaining the status quo and glorifying greed, wealth, and inequality...