2012 British GP @ Silverstone
in Formula 1 ·
Jason Campbell70 said:So, a modern NASCAR bike is rock solid in the rain?
Does a modern NASCAR bike have a carbon monocoque to protect the rider during heavy impacts?
Do F1 drivers die because they lose front-end grip?
Regardless, these guys get out there and bite at every single corner and every inch of the track, even when the front wheel is lifting off the ground during hard acceleration.
I think you might be using today’s qualifying session as a bad example. The bikes were riding in rain that felt significantly lighter than the downpour that actually forced the qualifying sessions to be red-flagged. I was watching those sessions myself...
Secondly, motorcycle riders don't deal with visibility issues nearly as much as F1 drivers do. That’s a massive factor. It's why bikers can tuck right behind an opponent, whereas in F1, doing that is incredibly difficult.
Personally, I wouldn't be so critical of the F1 drivers.
They are our eyes on the track, and they know exactly what they're dealing with.
If several drivers in a row are appealing to stop qualifying because driving is simply impossible, then driving probably really isn't possible.
Visibility was genuinely terrible before the stoppage... I remember looking at the onboard cameras and I couldn't even tell which car was ahead. It was just a wall of rain obscuring everything. What is a driver supposed to do then? Drive completely off the racing line?
And I honestly don't get those comments about how people used to race. How drivers back in the day had "guts" while today's drivers supposedly don't.
What does that even have to do with anything? If drivers twenty or thirty years ago risked losing control and crashing, today's drivers have to face those same risks.
Someone close to me has followed F1 for about 35 years, and they've told me a few times that races in the past only continued because there weren't enough smart people to call them off—and because the top brass didn't care about driver safety. Races used to end with multiple casualties, with constant red flags due to crashes. What was the point of that??
Bruno explained it perfectly today... what’s the point of racing if cars are flying off the track constantly and causing yellow flags? You can't even complete a standard lap without hitting a flag in every sector.
Or let's try another comparison... if you remember that documentary about the history of F1.
How previous drivers raced in cars that were basically made of "paper"... every crash was more violent, and it was all too easy for a driver to end up in a morgue the next day.
Those drivers were often labeled as having "guts." Well, fine—let's put today's drivers in those old cars and see them race. If the old crowd had guts, let today's guys prove they have them too.
If the old guard could do it, why can't these guys? That logic seems pretty flawed to me.
Just because the attitude used to be "I don't care if someone hits the wall" doesn't mean we should apply that mindset today.
That’s why I think today's qualifying was stopped for good reason. For me, it was simply unwatchable; I couldn't see a single car clearly, and people were spinning off the track constantly.