Karen Smith9 said:For me, the soundtrack was always the main event in that film. It works brilliantly as a standalone album—something you can just put on and enjoy—but when it’s layered over the movie, it feels incredibly overbearing. Take that famous, lighthearted theme when Claudia Cardinale gets off the train and wanders around waiting for her husband. It feels completely out of sync—just totally misplaced—much like several other scenes. And, well, as with pretty much any Leone film, the acting tends to be a bit over the top, though I suppose it works for the genre. My take? The music is frankly pretentious as a cinematic element, even if it's great when you listen to it solo. That seems to be the case with most Morricone work, really.
The thing is, modern audiences are so used to that kind of high-tech, sterile sound, so they might struggle with this. That’s why I see this film as art on multiple levels. The music isn't necessarily "too much"; rather, it sits right on that razor's edge of parody without ever actually crossing it, because the themes themselves are either breathtakingly beautiful, genuinely haunting, funny, or just plain tragic.
Every single character is given their own specific theme, and honestly, this movie simply wouldn't function without that score.
Claudia Cardinale has a theme that immediately communicates her femininity, her character, and sort of her tragic fate. That melody is also tied into the essence of the Wild West and the landscapes themselves. In a way, the music bridges her connection to the surroundings in such a positive light. The intro might feel a bit Italianate (beautiful regardless), but once the other instruments and the female vocals kick in, everything just clicks into place. I will admit, though, the theme during the finale might be a bit too dramatic.
Jason Robards was given this cool, effortless little theme that fits his character perfectly. He felt a bit like the Lucky Luke of the film. The music tells you right away that he isn't the villain, even if he arguably plays one.
Charles Bronson has a harmonica theme that weaves together with an electric guitar and an orchestral section reminiscent of a Henry Fonda score. In other words, through a single musical thread, the fates of two characters are linked—characters who become karmically inseparable through their shared evil. The harmonica lends Bronson a sense of mystery, since we aren't quite sure who he is or why he's there; the electric guitar hints at the darkness and brutality associated with Fonda; and the orchestral elements act as the glue binding their stories together.
Morton, who many viewers perceive as being purely negative, actually receives a small but incredibly moving theme. It doesn't reflect the outward wrongdoings he committed out of ignorance, but rather his inner self (which, let's face it, defines all the characters here). Through it, we see a nostalgic dreamer clinging to a vision he wants to live, but never will—whether because someone kills him or simply because he's too ill.
Looking back from today's perspective, whether it's the perceived sterility or the campiness, some might find parts of this film misplaced. However, the fact remains that this is the pinnacle of drama, executed in its most moving, artistic, and brilliant form in cinema history. It is, quite simply, a Western musical that actually works.