Sean Brooks said:So, I live right in the heart of the city, and I pay for a monthly permit for the red zone—which is supposed to give me the green light to park anywhere within those zones...
But honestly, that doesn't mean a damn thing because, as I’m sure you all know, finding a spot in our beloved New York City is an absolute nightmare. Today, in a fit of pure rage (mostly because there wasn't a single open space in sight), I ended up parking near the Department building since it looked empty... only for them to be "kind" enough to call the Spider service. They towed my car straight to their lot and, of course, charged me an absolute fortune for the privilege.($167)
So now I'm wondering—is there actually any way to fight this fine through an appeal?
Look, NYC Parking is basically a godsend, isn't it? They’ve just claimed every single parking spot for themselves under the guise that they "built" all the infrastructure and laid down every inch of asphalt in all of New York City. Apparently, that gives them the divine right to shake down drivers and residents whenever and however they please...
I assume the Department also pays (probably at a much higher rate) for monthly parking reserved exclusively for their staff. What I want to know is why us mere mortals—actual residents who pay our fair share—don't have even one single reserved spot available to us?
Isn't it a bit contradictory to sell permits and take people's money for a parking space that, in reality, you don't actually have? You just park wherever and whenever you can get lucky... imagine if you built a house somewhere outside of New York City and a crew from NYC Parking showed up to charge you for parking in your own driveway. But hey, that's just another robbery in a long line of schemes by the Government and their local cronies. Most Americans see right through it anyway, so what's the point in talking? Better to just stay quiet, right?
Anyway, getting back to my actual question: is there any real chance I can get this fine overturned with an appeal, or am I just stuck paying it no matter what?
NYC Parking is the agency responsible for managing parking throughout New York City. It's owned by the city, which owns all public spaces. So, technically, there's nothing wrong with NYC Parking collecting fees. Secondly, when you pay those $37 or whatever amount you're paying, you aren't buying a guaranteed spot; you're just buying the right not to pay the hourly rate. It costs a bit more, maybe around $1000 a month (could be more in the first zone).