Michael Jackson62 said:...
I didn't say that Extinction was a great movie. What I said was that, in my opinion, it’s the best installment of the trilogy. Here is my reasoning: when Anderson was writing the first film, he took the assignment far too seriously. Because of that, the end result sits in this awkward middle ground—it isn't quite ridiculous or bad enough to be considered "trash," yet it isn't actually good enough to be called a good film. Regardless, as the start of the series, it works well enough.
*Extinction* was a subpar film, feeling less like a cinematic adaptation and more like *Commando* dragged kicking and screaming into the 21st century. Honestly, that wouldn't have been a dealbreaker if this were just a standard action series, but when you're watching a *Resident Evil* movie, you expect at least a shred of survival horror. Instead, Paul W. S. Anderson completely gutted that atmosphere by turning Alice (Milla Jovovich) into a generic superhero. Her confrontation with Nemesis was so desperate and poorly executed that it nearly derailed the entire production. Despite its glaring flaws, the movie remains strangely watchable for some bizarre reason.
And this will come later...
It honestly looks to me like the directors are just absolutely thrilled to have Milla on board. It feels like they specifically engineered the entire scripts for the second and third installments just to force her character into the spotlight.
It’s an undeniable fact: since Milla is essentially Paul W. S. Anderson's future wife, she’s obviously going to be the center of attention. That was a major sticking point for me too, particularly during the second installment. However, by the third film, Anderson finally introduced enough supporting characters to pull some of the spotlight away from Alice. If we do end up getting a fourth part—which seems inevitable—I would personally love to see the focus shift away from her. Word on the street is that this might actually happen; Ali Larter mentioned that the producers want to set the fourth and final film in Alaska, featuring her in the lead role without Milla.
Even Mila-Fantasy, which peaked during that third installment, reached a point where the directors clearly had no idea how to capitalize on her character's success. Instead of doing something meaningful, they just churned out a trillion sequels. Now, in the fourth one, they’re planning to have her lead an entire army of clones to smash through everything with an umbrella.
🤣 I don't see that happening. Honestly, Paul W. S. Anderson just doesn't have the creative vision or the massive budget required to pull off a project of that scale.
It’s been five years since the events of the film, yet everything looks even more devastated than it did following a nuclear catastrophe—which, frankly, would have at least provided some semblance of logic to the setting. Instead, the world looks like only about 300 grams of time has passed. It is just complete, utter nonsense. You have this intense fight sequence right at the beginning, but once that's over, the entire movie devolves into nothing but heavy-handed clichés. They lean into that tired trope where everyone is suddenly part of this perfectly wholesome, tight-knit group, and then you have the ridiculous plot point where a character gets bitten and decides to keep it a secret instead of just shooting themselves in the head right then and there to prevent an outbreak.
I didn't mind it one bit, mainly because I walked in with the impression that Paul W. S. Anderson was just making a massive joke out of this entire franchise. This time around, he clearly wasn't taking anything seriously. Watching the movie felt like playing a game of "spot the reference." One scene borrows from Evil Dead 2 with the zombies whistling, then you have Alice dressed like Clint Eastwood, followed by a shot straight out of Star Wars, and another nod to Day of the Dead. There wasn't a single truly original moment in the bunch, yet somehow, it felt more fun and playful than the first two installments. If they aren't going to make something that actually respects the spirit of Resident Evil 4, then fine—whatever. If it’s going to be a circus, let them throw a damn masquerade ball. 🙂