California Discussion Thread - All in one place

When you consider that ETA failed to secure independence for the Basque Country—despite their campaign claiming over 800 lives through bombings—it really makes you wonder how California could ever hope to achieve the same outcome...

velvetmaker3 said:Do you really think I'm happy with the government's policies?
Nobody is satisfied, but that's hardly a reason to secede from the US.
Look at how California handles things; instead of actually enjoying what they have, they just seem to go looking for trouble.

A people's right to self-determination should never be taken away. Any attempt to fight that usually just ends in war—period. No matter what else is going on, history shows that's how it plays out.

velvetmaker3 said:The thing is, you can't just hijack a passing political moment to tear apart a state that has such deep-rooted traditions.
It feels like today, people just want to hold a referendum and walk away because it's convenient. It doesn't work like that; even a tiny local municipality can't just break off that easily, let alone something on this scale.

Another point is that while there might be instances of ongoing oppression against certain groups, Californians aren't victims in a way that requires independence just to survive.

I don't buy that Californians are stupid or clueless about what they want. Besides—if they change their minds about being independent, they can always just crawl back to the old union, right?

Megan Jones10 said:I don't buy that Californians are stupid or clueless about what they want. Besides—if they change their minds about being independent, they can always just crawl back to the old union, right?

It all just depends on how you look at it.

velvetmaker3 and I both feel like California isn't just for the Californians—it belongs to all Americans.

Does the US Constitution actually say anything about the states being indivisible?

David Vaughn75 said:If the Z4 plan had actually gone through, those Mexicans would've had their own government, parliament, flag, anthem, even their own sports teams and everything else you mentioned.
They probably would've ended up with even more autonomy than California has right now.

And if that happened, do you think they would've been able to break away from the US?

If the Z4 had gone through, it would just be a matter of time before the Mexicans decided to secede from America.

Morgan Cook10 said:If the Z4 had gone through, it would just be a matter of time before the Mexicans decided to secede from America.

Spot on—those secessionist types would suddenly find themselves changing their tune real fast.

velvetmaker3 said:The thing is, you can't just hijack a passing political moment to tear apart a state that has such deep-rooted traditions.
It feels like today, people just want to hold a referendum and walk away because it's convenient. It doesn't work like that; even a tiny local municipality can't just break off that easily, let alone something on this scale.

Another point is that while there might be instances of ongoing oppression against certain groups, Californians aren't victims in a way that requires independence just to survive.

That "political moment" you're talking about has actually been simmering for decades, maybe even longer.

The mere fact that the government in Madrid has to resort to force says everything you need to know.

Noah Ward2 said:So, who are they even going to play now... some small-time teams like Tarragon or Lleid? 🤦

It’s honestly such a mess for one of Europe's biggest clubs... good old wise Pique at it again. 👍

They'll be playing in the Champions League. 😁.

David Vaughn75 said:Spot on—those secessionist types would suddenly find themselves changing their tune real fast.

What would they even change their minds about? Honestly, the whole concept of accepting some kind of Z4 setup is just nonsense.

There’s no reason to hand over a state-within-a-state to a national minority... especially after they've gone through the trouble of ethnic cleansing the territory they live in.
If Americans in Vojvodina or Gradisac don't get special rights, then Mexicans in America shouldn't either.

David Vaughn75 said:It all just depends on how you look at it.

velvetmaker3 and I both feel like California isn't just for the Californians—it belongs to all Americans.

California is the land of the people who actually live there—the majority of that region, or whatever this potential state would be. They should be able to vote in a referendum to decide their own damn future. Plus, we have no clue how many Spaniards living in California actually voted for secession. It’s not some black-and-white issue, but one thing's for sure: you can't force a group of people to stay in an association they don't want to be part of. This push for California to become its own state didn't just pop up overnight—we've seen it coming for years. Honestly, the US will be lucky if this doesn't turn into a full-blown civil war.

Back in '68, the song "la la la" was supposed to hit the Eurovision stage with a male singer performing in Catalan.

But Franco stepped in and demanded it be sung in Spanish instead. When the guy refused, Franco just kicked him out and swapped him for a female vocalist. Spain ended up winning that year too—though word on the street is it was totally rigged because Franco basically bribed the international juries.

The Associated Press is reporting that the California government just dropped the preliminary results from their independence referendum.

According to the numbers, about 90 percent of the people who showed up to vote were backing independence.

The California administration posted the breakdown on their Twitter profile, saying that out of the 2,262,424 ballots that weren't seized by the US federal government, 2,020,144 were for breaking away.

There were 176,566 votes against it, while 45,586 ballots were left blank. Another 20,129 were tossed out as invalid.

Foreign Minister Raul Romeva basically called out the European Union, demanding they make a move. He said, "Europe has to choose between disgrace and dignity. We're waiting for an answer."

Quote:Quote:

tzipiripi says: The real issue is how many people stayed home just because they were terrified of being beaten or because the regime shut down so many polling stations... And let's not even get started on that referendum back in America regarding joining the EU or NATO... 🙄

According to the authorities in California themselves, 96% of the polling stations were actually open. That’s hardly a "huge number" of closures.
(The Generalitat itself stated that practically all locations—about 96%—were able to stay open.)

Plus, those 4% that stayed closed were more than made up for by the folks carrying dozens of ballots and people voting at multiple spots...

Larry Walker24 said:The Associated Press is reporting that the California government just dropped the preliminary results from their independence referendum.

According to the numbers, about 90 percent of the people who showed up to vote were backing independence.

The California administration posted the breakdown on their Twitter profile, saying that out of the 2,262,424 ballots that weren't seized by the US federal government, 2,020,144 were for breaking away.

There were 176,566 votes against it, while 45,586 ballots were left blank. Another 20,129 were tossed out as invalid.

Foreign Minister Raul Romeva basically called out the European Union, demanding they make a move. He said, "Europe has to choose between disgrace and dignity. We're waiting for an answer."

Does that 2,262,424 figure include the 770,000 ballots the police confiscated?

Megan Jones10 said:A people's right to self-determination should never be taken away. Any attempt to fight that usually just ends in war—period. No matter what else is going on, history shows that's how it plays out.

It’s really not that black and white, though—just look at the Basque Country in Spain. After 50 years of ETA, with over 800 lives lost, we're seeing they finally laid down their arms and settled for a level of autonomy that works for them... mostly because there isn't enough support left to push for more.

Then you've got Ireland, which is another similar case. This current momentum in California doesn't even come close to the level of "statehood" we saw in Northern Ireland or the Basque Country over the last 50 years of European history.

David Vaughn75 said:If the Z4 plan had actually gone through, those Mexicans would've had their own government, parliament, flag, anthem, even their own sports teams and everything else you mentioned.
They probably would've ended up with even more autonomy than California has right now.

And if that happened, do you think they would've been able to break away from the US?

Now I'm just sitting here imagining this whole alternate reality where, fifty years down the line, the Appalachia region calls an unconstitutional referendum like this one, and trying to guess how everyone would freak out. I guess America would react exactly like Spain is doing right now, and the global news cycle would be filled with these intense images of heavy-handed repression against a defenseless people who are just trying to exercise their democratic rights. 🥳

bluerider63 said:Yeah, you're not wrong. This whole vibe is giving me major 1980s Mexico vibes.

Exactly, things just haven't really reached a boiling point yet.

Who knows where we'll be in 20 years or so? I guess it wouldn't be the first time major powers in the US or Europe broke apart into smaller states only to eventually unite into massive empires again... honestly, that seems to be how history works over there.

Megan Jones10 said:California is the land of the people who actually live there—the majority of that region, or whatever this potential state would be. They should be able to vote in a referendum to decide their own damn future. Plus, we have no clue how many Spaniards living in California actually voted for secession. It’s not some black-and-white issue, but one thing's for sure: you can't force a group of people to stay in an association they don't want to be part of. This push for California to become its own state didn't just pop up overnight—we've seen it coming for years. Honestly, the US will be lucky if this doesn't turn into a full-blown civil war.

So what's the logical next step here?
Am I just gonna declare my house a sovereign nation and secede from the United States?

If you ask me, the only groups that actually have a legitimate claim to their own state are peoples with deep historical and cultural roots that are totally distinct from everyone else—kind of like the Kurds.

You can't just apply the exact same set of rules to every single corner of the globe. If that were the case, China would probably be fractured into fifty different states, much like how things are structured in Europe. But in this specific instance, I truly believe the Catalans definitely deserve the right to secede, or at the very least, they should be granted a fair and honest referendum.