Angela Newman33 said:Come on, someone needs to draw a line in the sand eventually... how much can we actually tolerate from one moderator just because they hold the title?
A community shouldn't depend on a single moderator running their own personal online jihad.
XX
Thank God you guys are here...
I came to this sub with the intention of filing a complaint regarding the way my post was flagged by the Orahov ISP on a controversial thread.
swiftorca57 is spot on when they say—and I mean this—that the other mods on the Religion sub are basically being manipulated by Shady, who seems to view that PDF as his personal mission statement and a tool to act far beyond the scope of enthusiastic moderation for this social space.
My plan was to start a thread titled "Islamism on the Religion sub" (treating Islamism as a term for political action).
Instead, I got slapped with a red flag for trolling and sexism. How?! EEK!
And all for a post in a thread asking "Why are people afraid of Islam? What's the harm?" which was actually the perfect antithesis to princessxx's argument in that specific discussion.
I backed up my points with real-life examples, keeping in mind the discourse of the topic where men and women are viewed and treated separately (purdah).
Not only did our arguments fail to reach any kind of synthesis—mostly because the topic was hijacked by a heavy-handed hand—but I ended up getting 35 penalty points after the thread was locked post-factum. In a fit of pure frustration (and having already been traumatized by the notification "You have received an infraction on Reddit"), I went to check if I’d been banned for being a complete idiot or some kind of vulgar person!
All this just because I want to exchange ideas with others and learn something through the fun, digital interaction of opposing views—engaging in dialectical, rational, and logical debate through cyber dialogue!
For instance: if I were to say right now that Islam doesn't recognize dialogue or any kind of debate, I'd be insulted first and then immediately banned on the Religion sub.
Rather than being talked down through a factual, dialectical conversation!
IMHO
Moderators are incredibly important—actually essential—for constructive, open dialogue within a subreddit.
They should be encouraging discussion, not stifling it or cutting it short.
Isn't the goal of any forum to have as many hits as possible, rather than a user base where half the active members are banned, or those who just lurk because they don't dare engage for fear of trauma, while a small circle of moderator favorites just roam along?