Overrated athletes?
in Other Sports ·
Jason Fisher78 said:rowdytinker3 and darkjackal70, let’s stop this amateur debate about who’s actually got more muscle and move on to something real.
First, I need to shut down that comparison darkjackal70 tried to pull with Bill Russell:
Seasons played
Bill Russell 13
Michael Jordan 15
Championships
Bill Russell 11
Michael Jordan 6
Conference Titles
Bill Russell 10
Michael Jordan 6
Times missing the Finals
Bill Russell 0
Michael Jordan 7
Times missing the playoffs
Bill Russell 0
Michael Jordan 2
Lost rings
Bill Russell 0
Michael Jordan 5
College seasons
Bill Russell 3
Michael Jordan 3
College titles
Bill Russell 2
Michael Jordan 1
College Final Four appearances
Bill Russell 2
Michael Jordan 1
Is anything unclear here?
For starters, you're comparing apples to oranges. But fine, whatever.
What exactly does this prove? That Michael Jordan is overrated? Or that everyone except Bill Russell is overrated?
Secondly, if you want to be fair, you should mention that during Russell's era, the league only had eight teams and two playoff rounds. You really ought to note that if you know what you're talking about.
What are you even trying to demonstrate? Personally, I don't claim Michael Jordan is the greatest ever. I think calling anyone the "GOAT" is impossible. There are a handful of players where you can honestly say they belong in that conversation—Michael Jordan is one of them. Just like Larry Bird and Magic Johnson. It's subjective. But saying he's overrated? Please.
I see people here calling Pete Sampras, Roger Federer, and Michael Phelps overrated... it's ridiculous. If they're overrated, then who isn't?